This liquid eyeliner is 'ok' in my opinion. The brush applicator is nice but it is hard to make a fine tip with this brush. The formula is long lasting and a nice black. The brush does not carry much product so I have to re-dip it 4-5 times per eye for enough product. The price is great, under $6 at drug stores. It comes in brown and black.
Overall I won't purchase this again. The formula is great but the applicator is pretty bad.